← Back to Retailer Search

The Etsy NOligarchy Profile

C
O
N
C
E
R
N
I
N
G
NOligarchy Score
45.7
/ 100
etsy.com
0
Etsy scores 45.7 out of 100 on the NOligarchy index — a number that sits below the midpoint and reflects a company making deliberate choices about where its money flows. From Q4 2024 through Q3 2026 (8 quarters — the two-year tracking period), the data captures a platform that markets itself as the champion of independent makers and small sellers while quietly channeling hundreds of millions of dollars into a mechanism that enriches its largest shareholders and top executives. Its clean regulatory record and modest lobbying footprint are real — but they don’t offset what’s happening on the payout side.
Current Pillar Scores
Political Access
40.8
Wealth Extraction
20.9
Playing by the Rules
100.0
Score history — 24 quarters
TRUSTEDMODERATECONCERNINGAVOIDNov '20 electionNov '22 electionNov '24 election62.245.7+0.1 · 1yrQ4 '20Q4 '21Q4 '22Q4 '23Q4 '24Q3 '26 · now
Tier bands show where each quarter's score falls — no numeric y-axis needed. The dashed ring marks the year-over-year comparison point. Tap any quarter but the first to see its pillar breakdown.
•
Political Access Grade: 40.81/100. Etsy spent $2.01 million knocking on doors in Washington and hired a lobbying operation staffed with former Hill insiders. No corporate Political Action Committee (PAC) spending was recorded, but the lobbying investment alone — and the revolving-door roster behind it — earns a low grade here.
•
Wealth Extraction Grade: 20.95/100. This is where Etsy’s score takes its heaviest hit. The company poured more than $1.5 billion into stock buybacks across the two most recent fiscal years, while paying its chief executive roughly 83 times what its median worker takes home, and disclosing no employee headcount that would allow a precise per-worker analysis.
•
Playing by the Rules Grade: 100/100. A perfect score. No recorded regulatory fines, no penalties, no public subsidies. The public docket is clean.
Etsy ranks 14th out of 21 companies among companies sharing its federal industry classification (Warehouse clubs, supercenters, and other general merchandise retailers). The sector average score is 53.6 — meaning Etsy trails the industry average by nearly 8 points. For higher-scoring places to shop in this sector, see the Better Alternatives section below.

The Bottom Line: A Brand Built on Small Sellers, a Balance Sheet Built for Shareholders

Etsy generated $2.88 billion in annual revenue while simultaneously spending $776.9 million on stock buybacks in fiscal year 2025 alone — nearly 27 cents of every dollar in revenue redirected away from operations and into a deliberate mechanism to inflate per-share metrics. That single-year buyback figure dwarfs the company’s entire lobbying spend many times over and would have transformed the lives of every person on Etsy’s payroll — if Etsy disclosed how many workers it actually employs. The company has built its brand on the back of independent sellers, craftspeople, and artists who depend on the platform’s reach, yet its financial decisions consistently prioritize the wealthiest shareholders over everyone else in the ecosystem. Its clean regulatory record shows Etsy can follow the rules when it chooses to. The question the data raises is which rules it has written for itself.
$2.1 million in political spending
Two-story house · 12 ft
0.6×
Stacked as $100 bills, Etsy's $2.1 million in political spending rises 8 feet — 0.6× the height of a two-story house.

Spending to Buy a Seat at the Table — With Hill Insiders in the Room

Over the two-year tracking period, Etsy funneled $2.01 million into federal lobbying — $250,000 in the fourth quarter of 2024, $990,000 across 2025, and $770,000 through the first three quarters of 2026. That investment bought access to both chambers of Congress (168 lobbying contacts each for the House of Representatives and the Senate), the Department of Commerce, the U.S. Trade Representative (USTR), the White House Office, the Treasury Department, and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), among others.
FEDERAL CONTACT LOG
HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
168
≈ every 3rd business day
SENATE
168
≈ every 3rd business day
Commerce, Dept of (DOC)
56
≈ every 9th business day
White House Office
40
≈ every 12th business day
U.S. Trade Representative (USTR)
29
≈ every 17th business day
15 federal bodies named in federal lobbying filings · 2024-Q4–2026-Q3
Between 2024-Q4 and 2026-Q3, Etsy was named in lobbying filings reaching 15 federal bodies — from HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES to SENATE.
The issue areas tell a precise story about the business pressures Etsy faces. Taxation was the most active lobbying territory with 31 filings, followed by Consumer Issues at 22. On taxation, filings cited Form 1099-K reporting requirements that compel payment platforms to report seller earnings to the IRS at much lower thresholds than before — a change that creates friction for the gig-economy sellers who are Etsy’s core constituency. Lobbyists referenced the Saving Gig Economy Taxpayers Act and both the House and Senate versions of the SNOOP Act of 2023, all relating to reporting thresholds and tax simplification for self-employed workers. Both versions remain in progress.
On trade — 16 filings — lobbyists described efforts around de minimis customs exemptions, digital service taxes, and intermediary liability protections. Any tightening of de minimis rules would directly raise costs for the overseas sellers and buyers who use the platform; any expansion of platform liability could expose Etsy to lawsuits it currently sidesteps. In copyright and trademark filings (15 filings), lobbyists referenced Section 512 of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) and raised concerns about the SHOP SAFE Act of 2023 — still in progress in the Senate Judiciary Committee — which addresses third-party marketplace liability for counterfeit goods. Etsy’s lobbyists also cited both the House and Senate versions of the App Store Accountability Act (H.R. 3149 and S. 1586, each referenced three times), which remains in progress in both chambers. On child safety, filings referenced the EARN IT Act of 2023 and the STOP CSAM Act of 2023 — both on the Senate legislative calendar — addressing online child sexual abuse material and platform responsibility.
To carry that access further, Etsy retains three outside lobbying firms. One of them — WilmerHale (Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and Dorr LLP) — also lobbies for Microsoft Corporation and Walgreens Boots Alliance, meaning Etsy shares a lobbying firm with major corporate players in different sectors, extending its influence through shared infrastructure.
Shared Lobbying Exposure
Etsy
client
WILMER CUTLER PICKERING HALE AND DORR LLP
lobbying firm
Microsoft Corporation
also a client
Walgreens Boots Alliance Inc
also a client
Why it matters: the same firm argues Etsy’s case and its rivals’ — one hire buys a web of shared access that can’t be seen from outside. This network worsens Etsy’s political-access score (see methodology for the exact factor).
Fourteen of Etsy’s 19 registered lobbyists have held government positions. Robert Lehman served as Chief of Staff to Senator Rob Portman, Chief of Staff at the Office of Management and Budget, Chief of Staff at the USTR, and spent a decade as Chief of Staff to House members Portman and Larry Combest. Jeffrey Zubricki served as professional staff on the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation — the same committee overseeing platform liability and trade legislation. Brian Skretny served as Legislative Director for Representative Eliot Engel and Senior Professional Staff on the House Foreign Affairs Committee. Jonathan Blum served as Economic Policy Advisor to Senator Todd Young and as Deputy Assistant Secretary at the Treasury Department. Between them, Etsy’s lobbying team carries direct institutional relationships with the precise committees and agencies overseeing every major issue area on the company’s dossier.
No PAC spending was recorded. Federal Election Commission (FEC) data shows $95,825 in personal political donations by Etsy executives and employees across the tracking period — the bulk of it, $62,000, concentrated in a single quarter (Q3 2025).

Prioritizing Wall Street Over the Workforce — One Buyback at a Time

The CEO pay ratio is 83:1, the 3-year average of Compensation Actually Paid, per the SEC DEF 14A — meaning that for every dollar the median Etsy employee earned, the person at the top collected eighty-three. The median employee salary was $218,815 — a figure that, in isolation, sounds comfortable. The CEO’s three-year average package was about $18.1 million, and that gap is not compensation for complexity. It is a structural decision to concentrate gains at the top.
Then there are the buybacks — and this is where the numbers become genuinely difficult to square with the company’s public identity as a platform for independent, working-class creators.
According to SEC filing data, Etsy spent $776.9 million in FY2025 — equal to 26.9% of that year’s total revenue — and $723.9 million in FY2024, equal to 25.8% of revenue. That is more than $1.5 billion across those two fiscal years, channeled into a deliberate reduction in shares outstanding that inflates per-share metrics and triggers executive performance bonuses, with the pace growing year over year.
In 2025 alone, Etsy chose to spend $776.9 million buying back its own stock: more than a quarter of its entire annual revenue, redirected not into the marketplace, not into seller tools, and not into worker paychecks — but into a mechanism whose primary beneficiaries are the wealthiest shareholders and the executives whose bonus formulas are tied to per-share performance.
Etsy does not publicly disclose its total employee headcount, which means a precise per-worker raise calculation cannot be computed. What can be said plainly: the $776.9 million handed to shareholders in 2025 alone represents a sum that, divided across any realistic workforce figure, would constitute a transformative raise for every person on payroll. For context, the $2.01 million Etsy spent on lobbying over the entire two-year tracking period amounts to about a quarter of one percent of what it spent enriching its largest shareholders in a single fiscal year. The company’s stated investment in shaping public policy for small sellers is, in financial terms, a rounding error against the buyback total.
Traditional dividends pay out proportionally to every shareholder, including small retail investors. Buybacks, by inflating per-share price, disproportionately reward insiders and large institutional holders who can time their exits to capture the premium. Buybacks concentrate gains most efficiently at the top.
Buybacks also reduce the number of shares outstanding, which arithmetically boosts Earnings Per Share (EPS) — the very metric most executive bonus and long-term incentive plans use as a performance trigger. The same executives who approved the $776.9 million in 2025 buybacks are the ones whose compensation packages benefit directly when EPS rises as a result.
Etsy’s tax position requires careful reading. The company’s 10-K discloses an effective tax rate of 33.9% for the year ended December 31, 2025 — 12.9 percentage points above the 21% federal statutory rate that Congress set, and 10.2 percentage points above the 23.7% median paid by companies in the same sector. On the surface, Etsy appears to be paying more than the law requires, not less. But the story behind that elevated rate is not a display of corporate tax citizenship.
The 10-K reconciliation shows the rate was driven sharply upward by specific items: valuation allowances added 15.2 percentage points ($37.571 million), a non-deductible goodwill impairment charge added another 8.7 percentage points ($21.358 million), and tax deficiencies from stock-based compensation contributed 4.9 percentage points ($12.078 million). Meanwhile, the filing explicitly identifies Ireland and the United Kingdom as foreign jurisdictions generating favorable rate differentials: Ireland delivered a −6.1 percentage point reduction (−$15.155 million), and the U.K. contributed an additional −1.3 percentage point reduction (−$3.278 million). The company also claimed research and development tax credits reducing the rate by 7.0 percentage points.
Etsy’s headline rate of 33.9% is elevated not because the company paid generously, but because specific non-cash charges and valuation allowances pushed it upward — while lower-rate operations in Ireland and the U.K. pulled it down. The company’s 10-K also discloses Pillar Two top-up taxes of $4.712 million (1.9 percentage points) attributable to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) global minimum tax framework — a cost the company now absorbs as more jurisdictions enforce the global floor. That 12.9 percentage point premium above the statutory rate was driven by non-cash accounting events, not generosity. On top of all this, Etsy holds Unrecognized Tax Benefits equal to 21.0% of its pre-tax income — contested deductions it has claimed on its taxes that the IRS has not yet agreed are valid. One dollar in every five of pre-tax income sits in a disputed gray zone with tax authorities.
Statutory federal rate
21%
Sector median
23.7%
This company
33.9%
Etsy's effective federal tax rate was 33.9% against the 21% statutory rate, and below the 23.7% sector median — -12.9 percentage points drained away.

A Clean Record on the Public Docket

There is nothing to prosecute here in the conventional sense. Etsy’s regulatory record shows zero fines, zero penalties, and zero public subsidies over the tracked period. On this pillar, the company scores a perfect 100/100 — the only dimension where its performance is unambiguous.
No Good Jobs First violations are recorded. No government grants or tax incentives appear in the subsidy database. For a company operating at $2.88 billion in annual revenue, the absence of any regulatory enforcement action is notable — and, on this metric alone, genuinely commendable.
Better Alternatives
DON'T JUST READ THE SCORE
Search any product in Shop to see how every retailer that carries it scores. Spend where it counts.
Shop with your values →
Political Access counts disclosed federal spending only. Dark money (501(c)(4) donations) is not included. How we score →
← Back to Retailer Search
N
ligarchy
Shop without feeding the Oligarchy.
© 2026 NOligarchy