← Back to Retailer Search

The Menards NOligarchy Profile

M
O
D
E
R
A
T
E
NOligarchy Score
66.6
/ 100
menards.com
0
Menards earns a NOligarchy Score of 66.64 out of 100 — a middling result driven by a near-perfect political footprint and a compliance record that keeps it anchored near the bottom of its sector.
Current Pillar Scores
Political Access
97.6
Wealth Extraction
51.7
Playing by the Rules
13.1
Score history — 24 quarters
TRUSTEDMODERATECONCERNINGAVOIDNov '20 electionNov '22 electionNov '24 election70.466.6−4.4 · 1yrQ4 '20Q4 '21Q4 '22Q4 '23Q4 '24Q3 '26 · now
Tier bands show where each quarter's score falls — no numeric y-axis needed. The dashed ring marks the year-over-year comparison point. Tap any quarter but the first to see its pillar breakdown.
•
Political Access Grade: 97.56/100. Menards registered zero in federal lobbying spend and zero in Political Action Committee (PAC) contributions from Q4 2024 through Q3 2026 — the full eight-quarter, two-year tracking period. The only trace of political spending is $176 in personal donations by employees who listed Menards as their employer, recorded in Federal Election Commission (FEC) filings. That is a vanishingly small footprint for a company of this size.
•
Wealth Extraction Grade: 51.74/100. Menards is privately held, so no buyback or dividend data appears in the public record. The CEO pay gap is estimated at 246:1 using industry benchmarks — meaning the person at the top likely earns nearly 250 times what a typical store worker takes home — but the exact figures are not publicly disclosed.
•
Playing by the Rules Grade: 13.13/100. Menards racked up $4,267,960 in regulatory penalties across 3 cases between October 1, 2024 and September 30, 2026, putting it in the bottom tier of its peer group on compliance. A $4.25 million consumer protection settlement alone accounts for the bulk of that bill.
Sector Context: Menards ranks 3rd out of 6 companies in its federal industry classification, Building Material & Supplies Dealers. The sector average score is 50.2 — Menards sits above it, meaning it outperforms its industry’s baseline primarily by staying out of Washington rather than by maintaining a clean legal record.

The Bottom Line: A $13 Billion Company With a Compliance Problem and a Hidden Pay Gap

Menards pulls in an estimated $13.1 billion in annual revenue, according to Private estimate (FORBES) — enough to rank it among the country’s largest home improvement chains. It has chosen to stay entirely out of federal lobbying and PAC spending, which is genuinely unusual at this scale. But what it avoids in political influence spending, it makes up for in regulatory fines: $4.3 million in penalties over two years, including a multimillion-dollar consumer protection settlement. And because it is privately held, the pay gap between the executive suite and the store floor remains completely invisible to the public — a gap the best available estimates put at nearly 250 to 1.

No Footprint in Washington

Menards is one of the few companies at its revenue scale that files no federal lobbying disclosures whatsoever. The Senate Lobbying Disclosure Act (LDA) filing search returns no active registrations for Menard Inc across the full two-year period from Q4 2024 through Q3 2026. The company operates no PAC and retains no outside lobbying firms. No former government officials appear on its payroll in a lobbying capacity.
The only political money connected to the company is $176 in individual FEC-reported contributions — from individuals who listed Menards as their employer in Q4 2024. That is not company spending; it is personal donations that happen to carry the employer’s name. For a retailer with over thirteen billion dollars in annual revenue, this level of political disengagement is a meaningful choice. The rules of the game — on labor standards, consumer protection, building codes, trade tariffs on lumber and hardware — are shaped in Washington every year. Menards has chosen not to show up.

An Undisclosed Pay Gap

Menards is a privately held company, which means it faces no legal requirement to publish executive salaries, total compensation figures, or the ratio of CEO pay to worker earnings. That absence of disclosure is itself a data point.
The best available estimate puts the CEO pay ratio at 246:1, based on AFL-CIO Executive Paywatch industry benchmarks for comparable companies in this sector. To put that gap in concrete terms: if a full-time Menards store worker earns roughly $35,000 a year, a 246:1 ratio implies the person running the company takes home the equivalent of what 246 of those workers earn combined. But because there is no mandatory disclosure, that number cannot be confirmed. Shoppers, workers, and policymakers have no way to verify it.
No stock buyback or dividend data is recorded for Menards — consistent with its status as a private company with no publicly traded shares. There are no shareholder return figures to analyze and no per-share earnings trigger to examine. What cannot be seen in the public record cannot be evaluated.

Fines as a Cost of Doing Business

Between October 1, 2024 and September 30, 2026 — the full two-year tracking period — Menards accumulated $4,267,960 in regulatory penalties across 3 cases. That record spans two distinct categories of violation: consumer protection and workplace safety.
The single largest penalty — and the one that defines the compliance story — was a $4,250,000 consumer protection settlement handed down in 2025 by multiple agencies. One settlement of that size, on its own, represents a meaningful accountability moment for a company that generates $13.1 billion in annual revenue. For workers in Menards stores and warehouses, that $4.25 million works out to less than one-third of one percent of the company’s annual sales — the kind of fine large retailers can absorb without changing behavior.
Alongside the consumer protection hit, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) issued two separate workplace safety penalties: $12,000 and $5,960 — both in 2025 — citations that indicate safety compliance at the store and facility level remains an ongoing challenge rather than a solved problem.
The Subsidy Flip: While regulators were fining Menards for breaking the rules, governments were simultaneously handing it public money. Between October 1, 2024 and September 30, 2026, Menards received $380,090 in public subsidies across three grants — primarily state tax credits. A Michigan tax credit worth $190,238 in 2025 and a Nebraska tax credit worth $189,852 in 2024 account for nearly all of it. The company collected taxpayer support at the same time it was paying out fines to regulators — 11.2 penalty dollars for every $1 in public subsidies received.
$380,090
taxpayer subsidies
$4.3 million
regulatory fines
11.2:1
Menards collected $380,090 in taxpayer subsidies against $4.3 million in regulatory fines — 11.2 penalty dollars for every $1 in subsidies.
Political Access counts disclosed federal spending only. Dark money (501(c)(4) donations) is not included. How we score →
← Back to Retailer Search
N
ligarchy
Shop without feeding the Oligarchy.
© 2026 NOligarchy